Skip to main content

Dog Play - Part 2

 This blog about dog play is not a stand alone piece. Please also read Part 1 as it's vitally important when you have dogs or have others' dogs in your care to know when something that might look like play is not play but something else entirely.
So now let's look at signs of good play.

Play as a state of mind

Play can be viewed as a state of mind. It involves its own neural structure in the brain1 and feels good because of the hormones and neurotransmitters it involves which include dopamine, oxytocin and endogenous opioids.

How do dogs let each other know it's play and not real fighting, biting and pursuit?

Play between dogs is made up from fragments of other behaviours such as predation, fighting and mating. Therefore there has to be a way to let each other know that it's “just pretend” so no one gets scared and the enjoyable state of play can take place.

Dogs do this by the use of 'play signals' to each other such as:

Exaggerated, inefficient movements – a clear signal that it's just fun

Self – handicapping and lack of defensive actions – lying on the ground, happily accepting another dog's 'bites' for example

Inhibited bites, with a lack of real targetted direction to them. Mouths will be held open in an exaggerated way. Look at the 'fierce' biting of the two puppies in the photo below to see a good example of this!

The open mouths during play will sometimes be accompanied by a 'wild-eyed' look. The white puppy in the photo below shows this look perfectly!
Lack of body tension - a 'looseness' to the appearance of the dogs' bodies when they are moving in play  

Taking pauses during play - a big part of good play

Taking turns at being the one being pounced on or chased etc. (role reversal)

Play bows – used to invite play, during play and as a way to keep play going

I have a good video to show you of two dogs playing. The dogs' names are Waffles and Molly. Waffles is the yellow labrador-looking dog and Molly is the little tri-coloured dog. They are sisters and live together. Let's watch them playing together:


In the video we see many signs of good play - Waffles lies on her back to invite play and Molly comes in for play biting. Their bodies are soft and relaxed and their mouths are open. 

Throughout this video the dogs demonstrate something essential in play and that is the mutual, voluntary nature of play - both parties must agree to it. In this play session, when one dog wants a break and then later signals a desire to end play, the other dog leaves her be. It is lovely to see.

They take turns chasing each other round the garden. When Waffles takes breaks in play by stopping and having a brief sniff of the ground or the air, Molly waits until Waffles indicates she is ready to play again. There is a lovely example (at around 28 secs. into the video) of the briefest of play bows by Waffles to get the play going again! 
During the biting on the run, it is the softness and lack of tension in their bodies that shows this is play. We can see their tails wagging softly at times during the play too. 

Having taken a few breaks, Waffles decides to end play entirely by standing still and disengaging. Molly seems to check-in with her to see if play will resume and then accepts play is over for now and wanders away.

Waffles then performs a shake-off.
There are different reasons for shake-offs. They are not exclusively used in the circumstances of shaking-off something stressful. They can be seen after play.2 They are also used for regulation of emotion.
I would interpret this shake-off by Waffles in this context as as a way of 're-setting' after play. She is coming back to normal after being in the state of play.

Waffles and Molly giving each other space at the end of the video and standing facing away from each other is polite canine behaviour. Each dog seems to be back in her own world again.

💗This blog is dedicated to the memory of Waffles who died on 23 October 2021

Ursula Linton

References, Notes and Acknowledgements

1. The PLAY system is one of the seven core emotional brain circuit systems first identified by Jaak Panksepp. The state of play as a state of consciousness is discussed by Mechtild Käufer in her book ‘Canine Play Behaviour. The Science of Dogs at Play' 2013 Dogwise publishing.

Photos of puppies (Leela and Liesl) from the Dog Decoder Facebook Page, with kind permission of Jill Breitner.

Video of Waffles and Molly with kind permission of Stef Dua.

2. Notes on shake-offs: I happened to be videoing puppies Pebbles and Bamm Bamm playing and captured a shake-off indicating the end of play:


We can see signs that it is good play. The lighter coloured puppy Bamm Bamm is in a self-handicapping position of lying down, happily accepting the play bites from Pebbles. It is Pebbles who signals the end of play with a shake off and the two puppies head off to do something else instead!

Remember that repeated shake-offs during play is not a good sign (as mentioned in Part 1). That is a sign that a dog is stressed/struggling with what is going on.








Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dogs Sniffing - it's even more important than I thought

 The first blog I wrote was 'The Importance of Sniffing on a Dog Walk' . Please check it out if you haven't seen it already. I've been inspired to write this further blog on sniffing because of information I've learned recently from an online talk 1  by  Shay Kelly BSc   (Canine Behaviour Consultant and author) and a webinar 2  by  Katrien Lismont   (International Pet Dog Behaviour Trainer). I knew that through their sniffing, dogs get interesting information about the other dogs that have passed that way – things like their age, health and so on. Generally interesting stuff for dogs. They also love investigating non-dog related stuff of course – things like discarded food wrappers for example! What I had never considered before Shay Kelly's talk is that dogs can smell the emotional state of other dogs 3  (and people). They can smell stress chemicals, for example. This will form part of the information dogs are assessing when they are out...
2 comments
Read more

Taking a curved route when walking towards your dog

Walking towards your dog, taking a curved route rather than a straight approach, is a nice thing you can do for him or her in your everyday life together.  Why would we do that? Dogs have a preference for non-direct approaches. Going straight up to another dog (i.e. direct route, body orientated straight-on, face to face) is generally not the way dogs go about things. Dogs who possess competent canine social skills, when going about their business, will communicate lack of intent towards those around them through the use of the direction they walk, the way they orientate their bodies relative to others, lack of direct eye contact etc. In addition, should socially competent dogs want to engage in a greeting, it will be a reciprocal arrangement involving curved/indirect approaches. If a dog is being aggressive or a dog wants to intimidate another dog that's when they are likely to use a direct approach. Alternatively, a dog may be over-excited and not have the social skills to put c...
2 comments
Read more

Dog Play - Part 1

 Dog play is a big topic so I am going to discuss it in two parts, like I did with 'Petting Dogs'. In addition, I will suggest some further reading in case you are really interested in this topic. Let's start by looking at what  isn't play Play between dogs has to be fun for each dog involved. It has to be voluntarily entered into and a dog has to be able to leave any time they want to . A dog won't play unless they feel safe,  both mentally and physically. They won't play if, for instance, they are afraid or if they are ill or in pain. This is really important and helps us to identify situations that might look like play, but may be something else entirely.  So when we think of a dog's need to feel safe as being an essential prerequisite for play, we can see that those 'play' episodes we sometimes see are not actually play. For example, one dog is bouncing happily round another dog and, although the other dog is responding, they are doing so...
Post a Comment
Read more